Why was my Thai student visa application denied at the consulate in Vientiane?

Nov 2, 2019
5 years ago
John *********
ORIGINAL POSTER
Visa Trip Report: Day 2, Part 2 (31 OCT 2019)

tl;dr DENIED

So this is what happened on Thursday but I’m only posting it now.

Arrived at Thai Consulate in Vientiane about 1:15pm.

Small cluster of people stood near the gate. Promptly at 1:30, the guard opened the gate and let everyone in.

We began to form a line at a window. Some of us thinking first come first serve and others of us using our queue number from yesterday to move back or forward.

This was all for nothing. A worker from the consulate came out and announced clearly, in English, what numbers to queue up for at window 3. Maybe about 25 numbers?

The majority of us were not called. The thought being: good to be in the majority and not the minority.

This moment was interrupted by another announcement of approximately a dozen numbers and were told to go to window 2.

This included me. Here I came face to face with the young man who took my visa application the day before. Well-dressed but not in uniform. He is a competent English speaker. His attitude hasn’t changed, which I perceived to be slightly impatient, not overly polite but not rude either.

“I’m sorry. We did not make a visa for you.”

Why not?

“I think because you study a long time already. How long did you study before?”

One year.

“Yes, that’s a long time for a beginner.”

Now I want to study at an intermediate level. I can speak, read, write, and type Thai. I have the bank statements you asked for yesterday.

“I don’t need them. Anyway, it’s not up to me, it’s up to my boss. He did not approve it.”

He gave me back my passport and all of the paperwork minus the application form. I did not pay any application fee.

What if I were to apply for studying Chinese?

“I wouldn’t know. That’s up to my boss to decide.”

Can I use this paperwork to apply in another country?

“You would need to have the letter addressed to the consulate you apply at.”

Whew. That’s not what I thought would happen. But it’s been the moment I’ve been fearing since August. Trying not to let it bother me too much. But preparing myself for the answer.

Worth stating, I never talked to an immigration officer. I was expecting a man (or woman) in his 50s, gold-rimmed glasses, in a uniform with badges and a name tag.

I never got to state my case. I was prepared to be interviewed.

Why do you want to stay in Thailand?

Why do you want to study Thai language?

What do you do for work?

How do you support yourself?

And expected to be quizzed in Thai. Maybe asked to write my name or something. I don't know.

At my request, my school prepared me another cover letter addressed to the Thai Consulate in HCMC Vietnam.

They had doubted I would receive my paperwork if denied but they’ve been wrong before and it’s small effort to print out another page.

Let me explain: Language schools, at least mine, are not visa authorities. They are a rumor mill. Some of the directors talk to each other and say where students were accepted and denied. But there is no rhyme and reason to this and the info is incomplete.

It’s the number one headache of my director. We don’t know. The government is doing their own thing.

For example: I was connected to a student who “had been denied in Vientiane but got a visa somehow”.

Turns out he wasn’t denied. He showed up without an appointment. He was denied from entering the Consulate. The how is another story and is subject to scrutiny at the present time.

I spoke to two other people who were denied after me. Both going for a tourist visa. One man, an Israeli, was told he had too many entries. That’s all I know.

Another man first came to Thailand in April this year on a Tourist Visa. Extended it. Bounced out at Mae Sai twice and extended those for his two visa exempt by land entries.

So he’s applying for his second SETV and he gets denied.

His plan was to fly to Luang Prabang and then onto Chiang Mai where the Airport Immigration has a friendly and accepting invitation.

Part 3: “So now what?” will come later today.
1,460
views
11
likes
43
all likes
23
replies
0
images
9
users
TLDR : Answer Summary
The post recounts a personal experience where the author applied for a Thai visa at the consulate in Vientiane but was denied. The reason given was that the author had already studied Thai for a year, which the consulate deemed as too long for a beginner. Despite having necessary documents, including bank statements, they were not considered by the consular officer. The author anticipated not being interviewed by an immigration officer, which added to the disappointment of the denial. Community comments provided additional context on visa application experiences and how different consulates may handle applications.
Ian *******
What school are you learning with OP and where is it?
Werner *******
Sorry to hear about your difficulties. So much has changed in the past couple years. When I moved here 5 years ago, a friend of mine had been living here on tourist visas for over 17 years. My, how things have changed...
Larry ******
immigration roulette
อาจารย์ ********
Can and will you share how much the minimum is needed on the bank statement?
อาจารย์ ********
Not about to show or not, but for an old bastard living in rural Thailand not visiting any bar or restaurant the rule is minimum 800.000 Thb for 1 year and for a young broke having the best time of his live, only needs 20.000 to live 1 year in Thailand. i now the prices, but that 20k is not going to last very long.
อาจารย์ ********
20k is for 30 days visa exempt, 20K is for 90 days with a tourist visa and 20K is for 1 year out of an ED visa. For the Visa Exempt I can understand, 20K for 1 month living is good, but to live 1 year inside Thailand on a budget of 20K is ridiculous .
John *********
ORIGINAL POSTER
If they do review your bank statements, they are looking for baht/dollar/euro equivalent of 20,000฿ or more.
อาจารย์ ********
it stays a mystery then
John *********
ORIGINAL POSTER
He didn't ask for an amount or a minimum or even specify a length of time to go back. In the end, it was all for nothing. He (and his boss) never saw them.
Justin *********
I’ve searched using a number of keywords in the ThaiVisa group for the supposed CNX denial and haven’t found anything.

There are a lots of things to be said about the mods over there but one thing is they’re pretty good at removing posts that are either fear mongering or when the situation presented in a post had more underlying issues past the norm. Since the post isn’t found I would guess that’s the case.

Which is to say, let’s not propagate rumors.
Steven ***************
@Maxim **********
. Until you know every person that has entered via DM or CM or accounted for all the denials that weren't advertised on social media, it's a lottery. Some people have more luck than others.

I've been questioned on a spouse visa /extension at DM and BKK airports.. What airport do you recommend for my next entry??
Ivan ************
"A little over a week ago when my extension was about to run out I thought it would be a good idea to just fly to Hong Kong for a couple of days, thinking it would still be ok to get a 30 day stamp when flying in. Turns out I was wrong. At Chiang Mai airport I was denied entry because I´d been in the country on a tourist visa for close to 8 months at that time."

***************************************************
*****
11-visa-woes/
Maxim ***********
I've searched for it as well, I'm usually great at it but found nothing. I live in Chiang Mai for a year and a half around 2015-2016, I don't know a single person who ever got denied there. My friend lives there for 10 years he never got into any trouble flying in CNX, or ask for any proof of. I live near Khon Kaen now and it's the same, although Khon Kaen immigration will ask for "proof of address", not very difficult to get. As a side note, I have avoided DMK airport for more than 5 years because everyone I know and trust told me they denied a lot of people.
Maxim ***********
Luang Prabang to Chiang Mai is fine, I did it a month ago on visa-exempt and I've been here a long time.

My friend got his Ed Visa in Vientiane last month to study Chinese (first year). He has been in Thailand for about 10 years. He almost didn't get it because the school wrongly check-box "2nd-year student" but it was his first. They interview him the day after and it was sorted out (he was able to come the next day with no appointment because of the confusion the day prior).

Bottom line is... it's Consulate dependent, always has been. HCMC is not an easy one.
Ivan ************
HCMC was very easy for Ed visas, including second year Ed visas, at least up until a few months ago. I got a second there over the summer. The worst reported out of there was a brief interview in Thai (really no pressure or anything complicated).

Hanoi went nuts on Ed visas only a few months ago, started rejecting almost everyone. But even after they went bananas people rejected there were able to go to HCMC and got their visas there. I did read reports of success in HCMC in the month following Hanoi clamping down.

I'm not sure if the policy change in Hanoi has affected HCMC yet. It's all changing fast, Vientiane and Savannakhet used be really fine for anything but now they have got really hardcore.
John *********
ORIGINAL POSTER
I'll add this to the main post: I never talked to an immigration officer. I was expecting a man in his 50s, gold-rimmed glasses, in a uniform with badges and a name tag.

I never got to state my case. I was prepared to be interviewed.

Why do you want to stay in Thailand?

Why do you want to study Thai language?

What do you do for work?

How do you support yourself?

And expected to be quizzed in Thai. Maybe asked to write my name or something. I don't know.
Ivan ************
There was a recent report on ThaiVisa of a German denied at CNX trying to get a visa exempt after a visa refusal. It's not a sure thing either. He had history although much it was non B. Better to use a friendly land border I think.
Ivan ************
I also got a grilling earlier this year _leaving_ Chiang Mai airport, where the IO told me I couldn't come back without a visa. It's certainly a better bet than the two Bangkok airports, but it's not a 100% thing, that's all I'm saying. There are certain land borders which I think you could say are still pretty much a 100% thing as long as you are within the clearly published rules (max 2 visa land exempts per calendar year).
Maxim ***********
Link please, if legit, this is the first case of denied on visa-exempt in CNX in 8 years.
Steven ***************
May I ask, what was your Thailand entry history prior to your first Ed visa? Is it possible it played a part in your denial?
Steven ***************
The only constant I've personally noticed on reports of denials are a history of back to back and/or multiple short term entries. And in most cases it's been given as a reason regardless of laws because of the discretion clause.

And let's remember, not every denial is going to end up posted on social media somewhere. Theres probably 100 more for every denial we hear about. Add to that, some people who do share it quite often dont tell the whole story regarding history.

Some people get denied early, some dont. Now that they are more vigilant about it, more will get denied, regardless of where they apply.

There are long term visas available, unfortunately some people dont qualify or can't afford them. Is it really any different to any other country?

Many are much tougher or impossible to stay long term on short term or exempt entry.

Just my opinion.

IO discretion is the key here. It's their job.

Anyone saying one entry point is better than another is total speculation. It guarantees nothing.

I was in queue at CM airport 5 years ago and watched 2 people get denied entry. Why I dont know. If anyone tells you it never happens there , they're misleading you.
Steven ***************
@John ********
. If they look at your passport while they assess your application, they're going to know it. That was the reason for my question. I dont know either way if it makes a difference but it wouldn't surprise me seeing they seem to target people who stay long term on multiple short entries.
John *********
ORIGINAL POSTER
My entry history was never mentioned. Not even in passing. If it played a role, I wouldn't know.

I had some Exempt entries and SETVs, did a one year ED visa which I got in Vientiane September 2018. Went to visa exempt while waiting for enough students to sign up for or finish the beginner level. (Rolling starts to the program.)

Now I applied for my second ED visa to learn Thai at Vientiane.
Thai Visa Advice and Everything Else
... members · 60% approval rate
The Thai Visa Advice And Everything Else group allows for a broad range of discussions on life in Thailand, beyond just visa inquiries.
Join the Group
Thai Visa Advice and Everything Else
View the Conversation
Thai Visa Advice and Everything Else