ask
Search
Ask
Unanswered16 days ago

What changes have been made to the group discussions and moderation guidelines for Thai visa-related questions?

7.4k
views
32
replies
26
likes
Group Drama & Updates:

More Open Discussions, Fewer Restrictions

We're making some changes to encourage more activity and open discussion within the group.

▪ Fewer locked threads: Discussions will remain open even after questions have been answered, allowing others to contribute.

▪ Relaxed post approvals: Questions don't need to be perfectly written or include every detail. As long as they're visa-related and not spam, they should be approved.

▪ Edit posts anytime: Missing details can be added later as the discussion develops.

▪ Less restrictive moderation: Moderators will focus on correcting misinformation and removing spam rather than limiting discussions.

Our goal is to create a more active, welcoming community where people can ask questions freely, share experiences, and help each other.

Good information is only useful if people actually get to see it.

Note: we apologize for the suspense caused by yesterdays post.

@everyone @topfans
Summary so far
Recent updates to the Thai visa-related group's discussion and moderation rules aim to foster more open conversations. Key changes include fewer locked threads, relaxed approval for posts, the ability to edit posts anytime, and a shift towards less restrictive moderation. However, many group members express concerns that these changes may lead to misinformation and a decrease in the group's overall quality and reliability.
32 repliesnewest first
16

Click comment and we will ask for your email, then OTP, then name.

Michael *********
Michael *********
train wreck incoming... just chasing the algorithm... damn the torpedoes... the fact TVC now has 2 groups with near identical names (one with 130k+ users, and one with 60k+ users) just adds to the confusion... from what I've seen so far its just a free for all on comments which makes both groups far less useful and trustworthy
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
OP
@Michael ********
The reality is that we need to adapt if we want to keep this group alive. The alternative is to simply shut it down and make the larger group a catchall for everything.

We decided to keep both groups alive because they serve different purposes. One focuses on DIY visa advice, while the other allows broader discussions, including assisted services.

If Facebook allowed groups to merge, we might have considered that option, but it currently isn't possible.
Bryan ***********
Bryan ***********
wow, he is a Facebook group moderator
Greg ***********
Greg ***********
big changes? MF? Did he refer to that ominous report from so called "Chiangraitimes" about changes in the policy of Phuket Immigration handling EOS applications? The report claims that now applicants who live in Thailand throughout the year (longer than 180 days) need to show Thai Tax Slips - confirming they have paid Thai tax or at least have Thai tax ID number and have done the reporting
James ********
James ********
@Greg **********
let's ask
@Stuart ********
for his take on this.
Tina ******
Tina ******
Visa still pending
BarryLi********
BarryLi********
Can u send that garrett bloke back to africa,seems like a cock tbf
Brian *******
Brian *******
@THAI *****************************
When you started sponsoring the group, your role in this group was limited to a sponsorship only - you were to take an active role in the other group. While I do appreciate your role in continuing this group as a sponsor, it's clear that your role has expanded.

We don't need more activity and open discussion - 'engagement' or what-have-you - nor do we want it - this is a Q&A group, not a discussion group. We have a very limited number of interactions with Immigration throughout the year ... but, when we do have to interact with them it is usually for matters that have very high practical and important significance in our lives. So, we need accuracy and a high signal to noise ratio and, up until now, this group has been really great in providing just that. That's the real value of this group and, in that regard, it has been a smashing success. Increasing discussion undermines both of these things. Moreover, many, if not most (?), of us are seniors, i.e. people who have little tolerance for nonessential information, much less the recent pettiness demonstrated by one of your moderators. Please learn how to read the room.

Can you please let us know what you think the purpose and value of this group is? And how your changes will serve this?
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
OP
I think we actually agree on the most important point: the purpose of this group is to provide accurate, practical Thai visa advice, particularly for people who want to handle their immigration matters themselves.

Where we disagree is on how best to preserve that value.

The reality is that this group has been declining in activity and reach for years. The information may be excellent, but it has little value if fewer and fewer people are seeing it or getting answers to their questions.

We're not trying to turn a Q&A group into a general discussion group. We're trying to make sure questions actually reach people who have the knowledge and experience to answer them.

Facebook has also changed how it distributes content. Repeatedly locking threads and restricting participation can limit visibility, even when the original question and answers are useful. Some of the group's most popular posts historically were locked threads, but that approach hasn't continued to work as well.

Our direction is straightforward: 𝗧𝗵𝗶𝘀 𝘀𝗵𝗼𝘂𝗹𝗱 𝗯𝗲 𝗮 𝗗𝗜𝗬-𝗼𝗻𝗹𝘆 𝗧𝗵𝗮𝗶 𝘃𝗶𝘀𝗮 𝗮𝗱𝘃𝗶𝗰𝗲 𝗴𝗿𝗼𝘂𝗽. We already have TVAEE for discussions involving agents and assisted services, as well as other groups for general Thailand discussions.

We want to maintain accurate information, encourage members to correct misinformation, and allow the community to recognize helpful answers through likes and engagement rather than automatically closing discussions.

We also don't believe questions need to be perfectly worded before they're approved. Members should be able to ask questions, clarify details, and update their posts as needed.

As for the recent moderator interactions, I agree that unnecessary pettiness has no place here, regardless of who it comes from.

Ultimately, the goal isn't engagement for engagement's sake. 𝗜𝘁'𝘀 𝗸𝗲𝗲𝗽𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗴𝗿𝗼𝘂𝗽 𝘂𝘀𝗲𝗳𝘂𝗹, 𝘃𝗶𝘀𝗶𝗯𝗹𝗲, 𝗮𝗰𝘁𝗶𝘃𝗲, 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗳𝗼𝗰𝘂𝘀𝗲𝗱 𝗼𝗻 𝗵𝗲𝗹𝗽𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗽𝗲𝗼𝗽𝗹𝗲 𝗻𝗮𝘃𝗶𝗴𝗮𝘁𝗲 𝗧𝗵𝗮𝗶 𝗶𝗺𝗺𝗶𝗴𝗿𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗺𝘀𝗲𝗹𝘃𝗲𝘀.

A group can have excellent information and still slowly become irrelevant if nobody is participating. We're trying to prevent that while preserving what made the group valuable in the first place.
Brian *******
Brian *******
Thanks but there are better alternatives. Good luck.
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
OP
@Brian ******
The purpose of a community is for people to see information, share experiences, ask questions, and learn from one another.

If nobody is seeing the content, then the group simply isn’t functioning as intended. At that point, we might as well replace it with a support email address.

A group should function as an active community, not just a private help desk (before it actually used to be ok, as facebook would show the content even when things were locked down).

We understand that not everyone will agree with these changes, and that’s perfectly fine.

Another important change is that the group is no longer private. It is now public, allowing more people to find, read, and benefit from the valuable information and advice shared here.

This also means you no longer need to be a member to access the information. If you disagree with the direction the group is taking, you’re absolutely welcome to leave and still benefit from the content whenever you need it. Membership and participation are entirely optional.
Biff *******
Biff *******
That’s a shame. This was pretty much the only Thai visa related group where the moderation was tough enough to maintain strictly factual information that we could pretty much guarantee was 100% accurate.

Now we’re going to get Jimbo from Jomtien expressing his opinion as fact, and endless commenting about 14 different immigration office’s varied regulations on the expiry of bank letters when the question asked was answered last week about a specific office in Nakhon Nowhere.

Ah well, it was good while it lasted.
Jyrki *********
Jyrki *********
Biggest problem IS that many people Post false information. Why Post If not real and useful? IT IS only causing confusion!
Russell ********
Russell ********
Jyrki Mattila nobody deliberately publishes wrong stuff. Its a complex area and people male mistakes. If it were easy, Visa agents would not exist.
Vladimir **********
Vladimir **********
Jyrki Mattila because it's Thailand and what's true for Bangkok can be false for Phuket 🤷‍♂️
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
OP
@Jyrki ********
Anyone can help correct misinformation, and a well-functioning group naturally does this by challenging inaccurate answers and liking helpful, accurate information so it rises to the top.

This approach has worked very well in our other group. Thailand Visa Advice | DTV | Retirement & More

These additional interactions also help the original question reach more members, giving more people the opportunity to see it, share their experiences, and contribute to the discussion. This increased engagement helps the entire group grow and remain active.
Steve *************
Steve *************
This has always been a great site without drama, till yesterday.

What made the site great was straight forward answers and locked posts, which actually stopped the drama.

If yesterdays post was any indication of how things will be with childish behavior and rude answers by one of your new mods, it's only going to tank this site
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
OP
@Steve ************
The concerns are understandable, but the reality is that the group is already pretty much inactive, and its reach has been declining for years.

In the past, locking posts worked well. In fact, some of the group’s most popular posts were locked ones. However, Facebook’s algorithms appear to have changed, and locked discussions no longer seem to get the same visibility they once did.

There needs to be a better balance. Instead of locking posts as soon as a question is answered, discussions should remain open, allowing members to like the most helpful answers so they naturally rise to the top.

The goal isn’t to introduce drama or lower the quality of the group. It’s to bring the group back to life while keeping it a useful resource for everyone. Standards can still be maintained without locking every discussion.
George ********
George ********
I've always thought this site is great. Whenever something was closed it was because it had been addressed earlier, or because it was a bit too personal. What's changed?
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
OP
In the past, moderators locking posts was never really an issue. In fact, some of the group’s most popular posts were locked ones. However, over time, Facebook appears to have changed how these discussions are surfaced in people’s feeds, and the group’s overall reach has continued to decline.

We need to find a better balance. Instead of locking posts once a question has been answered, we should let the community help surface the best information. Members can like and react to the most helpful answers, naturally pushing them to the top and giving them more visibility.

This keeps discussions active, helps useful information reach more people, and prevents valuable answers from getting buried or hidden.
Brian *******
Brian *******
@THAI *****************************
I counted 11 new visa-relevant posts in the last 24 hours. Why is more activity necessary?

People ask visa-relevant questions and consistently get quality answers. Yes, the moderation approach is unconventional but it has worked well in the context of this group. IMHO, no need to fix something that is not broken.
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
OP
@Brian ******
Approvals of those posts were delayed quite a bit, and approved in a burst. At the moment it's an average of 1-3 a day.
Jean *************
Jean *************
The only group drama is if
@Tod ********
is gone
Greg ***********
Greg ***********
Jean Miserendino sorry but I think Tod Daniels has never been a moderator in this group. He is present in other groups
James ********
James ********
@Greg **********
@Tod ********
has been and is The Legend of Thai Visa Advice. Sharing his expert advice with thousands of tourists and expats seeking correct Thai Visa Advice.
Greg ***********
Greg ***********
@James *******
Yes. The "Thai Visa Guru". I had the pleasure to share private messages with him a few times, again and again
Michael ********
Michael ********
Jean Miserendino ahaahh, nah Tod is cool. The other grumpy bum not so much.
Jean *************
Jean *************
Michael Carton grumpy bums are sometimes a necessity, known as the equalizers, to counter the flaky bums.. 😊
Michael ********
Michael ********
Jean Miserendino Ok lip plumper
Greg ***********
Greg ***********
Michael Carton with the "grumpy bum" I guess you mean James Miller. Or Robert Lagas. I agree that communicating with the second one mentioned can be a bit hairwiry
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
OP
@Jean ************
No moderator removals have taken place.

Additionally Tod has been promoted to moderator in the other group as well.

Thailand Visa Advice | DTV | Retirement & More
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
OP
Also a note on moderation, some of you may see some new faces, but it's important to note the moderation that were added to this group are from our other group:

Thailand Visa Advice | DTV | Retirement & More

Activity

16 joined
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
THAI ******************************
16
people
Thai Visa Advice
Thai Visa Advice
...members40% approval
Member 1
Member 2
Member 3
Member 4
Member 5
Member 6
Member 7
Member 8

Related

24
How can we deal with trolls in expat forums discussing Thai immigration and visa issues?
9.2k521705mo
Is anyone in this group affiliated with Thai Visa-related government officials?
1.1k762y
What support options are available for DIY visa help in Thailand?
1.3k5142y
What are the guidelines for joining the DIY visa help group?
57852y
What are the rules regarding visa dates if I travel to Thailand before 18th August?
3.6k26363y
What are the key features of the DIY visa help group for newcomers in Thailand?
724153y
What should new members know about this DIY visa help group?
645143y
What is the purpose of this group for new members seeking visa assistance in Thailand?
845283y
What are the official rules for posting in the Thai Visa Advice Facebook group?
2.9k10503y
What were the results of the recent poll about the moderation policies in the Thailand Visa group?
33.2k529553y
What are the key guidelines for participating in the Thailand visa advice group?
19.4k345424y
Why should discussions about visa procedures remain in the group?
7.2k102004y
What does the acquisition of the Thai visa advice group by Thai Visa Centre mean for its members?
33.4k1467155y
What are the Posting Guidelines for Visa Advice in This Community?
2.3k657y
Should the term "Advise" be changed to "Advice" in the group name?
3.5k28347y
What are the rules for posting on a Thai visa advice page?
6.8k131817y
Why are comments often closed in the Thai Visa Advice group?
3.9k51067y
What are the main rules and guidelines for asking questions in the Thai Visa Advice Group?
5.3k1637y
Why was my post deleted on the Thai Visa advice page?
1.6k12128y
What are the challenges expats face when seeking advice on Thai visa rules and regulations?
8.4k341728y
What are the rules for joining the Thai Visa Advice group?
75998y
What is the new visa initiative being discussed in Thailand, separate from the Smart Visa?
8903119y
Why is this group so valuable for visa advice in Thailand?
21.5k605479y
What should I do if my post about visa issues generates confusion and off-topic discussions?
5.5k231099y

Resources

Need help with your Thai visa?