@Phil ****
nope, you can't use Coral Gables for anything other than MAYBE a 90 day single entry Non-O visa (if they can even issue that) or a tourist visa. They can't issue multi-entry visas.
There is no 5 year retirement visa :/ It's actually a 10 year Non-Immigrant Type O-X visa. I have only seen people get them from the thai consulates in their country BEFORE they come here. I have never seen one issued inside the country (not that it couldn't be, but I've never seen it.
I would say it's not risky at all to apply by mail for either the O-A or the O-X. Read the requirements, MEET the requirements follow the procedure to mail it in and to get your passport back and you'd be fine. The thai consulate in Washington DC is pretty easy to deal with and I know people who use them routinely for visas to thailand by mail.