@Bill ********
Easier to apply in the USA but you may be required to leave the country every 90 days as I don't think there is a true 12 month marriage visa offered outside of the country. They call it a 12-month marriage visa (which is what it is) but you can only spend 90 days at a time, unless you get a 60 day extension (which can be done on each entry) though that's usually more trouble than it's worth I find. Easier to leave the country and come back the same day on a border run (sometimes referred to as a visa run, even though you're using the same visa) than bother with the 60 day extension, which requires the presence of your wife, payment of a 1900 Baht fee (going to the border and back often costs less than this, including the visa fee, if any, on the other side).
You could also use an agent for the extension, which avoids you having to deposit the funds yourself. Seek out the right agent (some are dodgy) but if you ever need to change to a different visa, you'd want to leave the country first and then come back with a fresh visa, rather than doing a conversion as that may not be allowed. This includes transferring to a different office and doing the extension yourself, after a year or two of being on agent assisted extensions.
A lot depends on your lifestyle and whether you'll be doing much traveling.