Ask question

Is it foolish for my friend to report her earnings in Thailand despite a 15% Self Employment tax?

Self Employment Tax Tax Obligations U.S. Taxes Visa Regulations Work Permits Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE)Thai Tax System Expatriate Advice IRS Rules Social Security Contributions

Feb 22, 2023

2 years ago

ORIGINAL POSTER

Hello. I have an American friend living in Thailand who teaches online for a small Chinese company. She recently discovered that she will have to pay 15% Self Employment tax if she reports her earnings. Do any of you think she is foolish for reporting this? 😀

4,566

views

7

likes

102

all likes

37

replies

3

images

21

users

TLDR : Answer Summary

The conversation centers around whether an American expat in Thailand should report her earnings from teaching online, considering her obligations to pay a 15% self-employment tax. Various opinions are shared: some advise that reporting is crucial to avoid legal trouble, while others suggest that as long as her income is below certain thresholds, she could avoid tax obligations. The discussion also touches on the legality of her work situation in Thailand, the implications of not reporting income, and the potential benefits of paying taxes for future social security.

Roy ***********

This might apply, you would need to very carefully read the requirements to determine how the days are counted, it is not a simple determination of what is considered physically present in a foreign country.

Who qualifies for the foreign earned income exclusion?

A U.S. citizen or a U.S. resident alien who is physically present in a foreign country or countries for at least 330 full days during any period of 12 consecutive months.

***************************************************************************************

Like

Reply

Stanley **********

Your Social Security retirement is based on what you claim as earnings. If you don't claim all your earnings, your retirement will be reduced forever. Up to you. I have a friend that is a retired bartender, he never claimed his tips and now his retirement check is 30% of mine.

Like

Reply

John ******

ORIGINAL POSTER

Thank you everyone for your replies. I always get helpful information here.

Like

Reply

Jw ********

Await the 250,000 baht fine and deportation with 5 year ban!

Like

Reply

Luke *******

Dont report. Easy.

Like

Reply

Cris ********

Sounds like she is well under the Standard Deduction. Plus she could be claiming the FEIE exclusion.

Often the self employment tax is paid online quarterly through the EFTPS website. I’m self employed too and I only pay in about 10% though.

I have variable income from year to year though and claim FEIE based on the Physical Presence Test since the online business I own is back in the US.

If she wants to consult with my tax specialist, I can share his info. He focuses on taxes for US Expats and Nomads.

Like

Reply

Michael *******

Like

Reply

Robert ************

There is NO USA TAX and NO OBLIGATION (to pay tax or to file Tax Return) -- IF that is her only taxable income. Standard Deduction for Single Filer is $12,950 for 2022.

Like

Reply

Greg *********

@Robert ***********

**********************************************************************************************

Like

Reply

Robert ************

P.S. BUT NOTE: For those of us Ex Pats from USA, regardless of whether or not you need to file a Tax Return, IF you have a Thai Bank Account (or any foreign Bank Acct). with more than USD$10,000 equivalent, is is MANDATORY to separately file an annual FBAR/FINCEN Report with the US Treasury, or you will be subject to hefty Penalty/Fine!

Like

Reply

Robert ************

What is your point? I am well aware of IRS Rules. And, my comment above is absolutely correct.

Like

Reply

Greg *********

@Robert ***********

I was under the impression, according to that link, that income level did not negate the requirement to file. That's all. Social Security Contributions and Benefit has already been touched on by others.

Like

Reply

Robert ************

Nope. As stated in your posted article above: "...the rules for filing income, estate, and gift tax returns and paying estimated tax are generally the SAME whether you are in the United States or abroad". See Also:

**************************************************************************************************************

Like

Reply

Reply to

Robert ************

Reply

Aaron *******

I believe the consensus answer is: "Forget about it." (American Cinema joke). 😎

Like

Reply

Aaron *******

If your talking about US taxes, minimum income to be required to file a tax return 12,950 USD. So, no need to report to IRS, if income is under this.

Like

Reply

Mark **********

Doing things legally is not foolish

Like

Reply

Chris ******

Works online , at home , virtually no chance of being caught … don’t worry about it

Like

Reply

Kool *******

It is illegal for her to work. She should be aware that the cut-off for paying Thai income tax is bt100,000. Below that number there is no tax owed. If she only made bt30,000 then no tax is owed, no matter what illegal work she does. She does not have to file. If she had a work permit she would have to file in order to get the receipt of filing so she could renew her work permit, but because she is working illegally that is not a concern

Like

Reply

Paul ********

Very Silly

Like

Reply

Paul ********

Idea! Give me the 15% and say nothing to anyone 🕶

Like

Reply

Kathalyn *******

I thought it was illegal to work on retirement visa??Perhaps I am wrong.

Like

Reply

Larry ******

@Kathalyn ******

Like

Reply

Kool *******

@Kathalyn ******

you are correct. It is illegal

Like

Reply

Reply to

Kool *******

Reply

Braulio *********

The self-employment tax rate is 15.3%. The rate consists of two parts: 12.4% for social security (old-age, survivors, and disability insurance) and 2.9% for Medicare (hospital insurance).

Like

Reply

Aaron ******

I think she is foolish if she doesn’t report it.

Don’t lie to the irs.

Just do proper write off and etc.

And consider the 15% an investment that pays out as social security payments later.

She likely isn’t making enough for this to make much of a difference anyways.

Like

Reply

Braulio *********

Pay the tax. It’s her obligation

Like

Reply

Robert ************

@Braulio ********

There is NO TAX and NO OBLIGATION (to pay tax or to file Tax Return) -- IF that is her only taxable income. Standard Deduction for Single Filer is $12,950 for 2022.

Like

Reply

Delvonte ********

This is for those spreading the misinformation. She is an independent contractor very very likely and she has to file . Don’t influence her into thinking what she might do is actually legal .

Like

Reply

Delvonte ********

Incorrect information. What Youre missing is that she’s self employed . The requirement is based on you not being self employed . She has to file if she made more than $400 and yes she’ll have to pay

Like

Reply

Reply to

Delvonte ********

Reply

Phil ********

What kind of visa does she have? Does she have a work permit?

If she has neither, and gets caught out; 15% tax will be the least of her troubles...

Like

Reply

Larry ******

Of the 10's if not 100's of thousands of people who have taught online in Thailand, I have not heard of one getting busted. You fear mongers are hilarious.

Like

Reply

Phil ********

Employment prohibited or married to a Thai?

Like

Reply

Michael ********

i have paid tax without a work permit, all they were interested in was the money. Was quite a funny interview

Like

Reply

Sam *****

@Michael *******

I can imagine this true. Money talks in Thailand

Like

Reply

Reply to

Sam *****

Reply

John ******

ORIGINAL POSTER

She has a retirement visa now and only makes about 30k baht a year.

Like

Reply

John **********

working is not allowed on a retirement visa.

Like

Reply

Aaron ******

basically $1k US a year? Self employed? And she can’t turn that into a loss with write offs?

Come on. She could literally buy a phone or computer and take it as a business write off and the profit would be gone.

Likely could offset other income and lower her taxes.

Just be careful to show a loss in too many years in a row.

Like

Reply

Reply to

Aaron ******

Reply

Thai Visa Advice and Everything Else

... members · 60% approval rate

The Thai Visa Advice And Everything Else group allows for a broad range of discussions on life in Thailand, beyond just visa inquiries.

Thai Visa Advice and Everything Else

View the Conversation

Thai Visa Advice and Everything Else

What Should an American Know About Taxes While Living in Thailand on a DTV Visa?

35 comments

2 months ago

Do expats in Thailand have to file a tax return after 180 days of residence?

184 comments

2 months ago

What documentation regarding income tax for foreigners in Thailand, especially retirees, is available in English?

11 comments

2 months ago

How will the proposed foreign income tax in Thailand affect expats planning to stay longer than 180 days?

17 comments

2 months ago

Is online trading considered a remote work activity for tax purposes in Thailand?

6 comments

2 months ago

Is the concern about visa issues in Thailand justified or just scaremongering?

40 comments

2 months ago

What are the tax implications of a retirement visa versus a marriage visa for expats in Thailand?

55 comments

3 months ago

What tax implications does a UK employee face when working remotely from Thailand?

4 comments

3 months ago

What are the implications of the recent changes in Thailand's tax laws for expats?

114 comments

3 months ago

What are the implications of the new Thai tax policy for retirees bringing money from their home country?

87 comments

4 months ago

How will Thailand's new tax law on foreign-sourced income affect foreigners living in the country?

16 comments

4 months ago

How to file taxes in Thailand after staying over 180 days, and who monitors your stay?

67 comments

4 months ago

What are the key considerations for expats regarding the Thai tax system and related visas?

28 comments

4 months ago

What are the implications of the new foreign income tax rules in Thailand for expats?

12 comments

5 months ago

Have expats experienced double taxation in Thailand despite the DTA?

94 comments

5 months ago

What are the implications of recent taxation discussions for expats in Thailand?

30 comments

5 months ago

What are the tax implications for expats in Thailand considering a retirement visa or long-term visa?

77 comments

6 months ago

Do I need to file a tax return in Thailand if I bring US-taxed dividends and the Thai PIT is lower than 15%?

24 comments

7 months ago

What do I need to know about the new tax law for foreigners staying in Thailand long-term on an education visa?

12 comments

8 months ago

What are some recommended expat tax services for US citizens living in Thailand?

11 comments

8 months ago

How can expats effectively manage tax exposure with new Thai tax rules starting in 2024?

96 comments

9 months ago

What are the tax implications for UK retirees spending over 180 days in Thailand?

50 comments

9 months ago

How can I manage tax obligations while on a NON-O volunteer visa in Thailand with foreign income?

15 comments

2 years ago

Do I need to file personal income taxes in Thailand if I received my work permit in December?

7 comments

3 years ago

Does my partner need to pay UK tax on his earnings from working in Thailand?

12 comments

7 years ago

Data protection policy Terms and conditions Disclaimer Privacy policy Refund policy

The asq:thailand community, consisting of multiple Q/A groups with over 100,000 members, powers this platform. It is not an official government resource. Our members actively contribute to this resource, and while we strive for accuracy, we cannot guarantee its complete reliability. Assistance to travelers is provided as a community service.