@Matt ******
89 days from your arrival date is Oct 26th, SO if you already were on a long term extension; where you were doing 90 day reports before you left that's when your next one would be due.
Getting a new extension doesn't affect the 90 day reporting dates UNLESS they give you a NEW 90 day report receipt when you get the extension (which I guess they didn't seeing as you're asking about when your report would be due 😛)