@Brandon ***********
I agree, that's a very accurate overview, I've spent some time in both...Hatyai has such an interesting vibe , vibrant music scene ,cultural mix food scene and very few non Asian farang..less traffic...beautiful nature nearby in Trang Province with terrific islands...Songkhla old city...I feel.like phuket has become a place about creating a ' paradise within the paradise' to avoid the at times overwhelming tourism.